Fact
Outlets describe a CNI report to Judge Tardón: no evidence of instigation, to date
Permanent link https://ceutafacts.org/en/fichas/cni-evidencias-20261116/
On 16 November RTVE, Europa Press, El País and El Mundo describe a CNI report dated 11 November and sent to Judge María Tardón. As they quote it, the CNI has not obtained, to date, evidence that the entries of 30 and 31 July were instigated, planned or coordinated by the Moroccan authorities. That is the CNI’s conclusion, according to those outlets. This archive has not seen the text. The CENIF report that names 18 officials is another body’s conclusion, on another card. The two are not merged. “More than 80,000” and “at least 80,000” are the outlets’ figures. They are not adopted and are not merged with 72,000 or with 88,146. A later CENIF report keeps “autoría difusa” and describes 97 connections that “could belong” to members of Moroccan security. That is the CENIF’s conclusion. It is not resolved with the conclusion of this text.
- Europa Press, which says it has seen the report, quotes the CNI: “From the investigations carried out by the CNI into the mass entry into Ceuta, no evidence has been obtained, to date, that would allow one to state that the events of 30 and 31 July were the result of an action instigated, planned or coordinated by the Moroccan authorities.” RTVE and El País quote the same limit, “to date” and “as far as is known at this moment.” El Mundo writes that the text is nine pages and that Judge Tardón had found the first information insufficient. “To date” stays in the sentence. This archive has not seen the document.
- The same outlets quote a second CNI sentence: the Moroccan authorities knew of calls of a mass reach urging people to enter Ceuta, and the decisions they took before and during the event prioritised the security of the Throne Day celebration, with King Mohammed VI at the nearby royal palace of Rincón. RTVE quotes that those decisions “had as a consequence the uncontrolled entry of people into the autonomous city without their meeting effective opposition from the Moroccan authorities.” That sentence is about a consequence the outlets attribute to the CNI. It is not a finding that Morocco designed the entry, and it is not a finding that Morocco had no part in what followed. Both sentences stay, each as quoted.
- El País quotes the CNI as saying that “from a purely theoretical or hypothetical point of view” a movement of that size “can be designed, driven and coordinated by the state apparatus of a regime” that had decided to use migratory pressure “as a tool of hybrid action.” In that supposition, the outlet writes, it would imply a “concerted state action that would require authorisation at the highest level.” The same paragraph says the investigations have not found evidence that would point directly to Rabat. The hypothetical is the CNI’s framing, as El País quotes it. It is not a finding. This card does not take anonymous commentary from other pieces.
- On 17 November El País writes that the CNI describes up to ten differences with 2021. The headline says the report is to “excluír” Moroccan authorship. “Excluír” is the headline. The body says that, after an “in-depth investigation,” the CNI has not found “evidence” that Rabat orchestrated the assault as it says happened in 2021. The outlet’s sentence that this “thesis reinforces the line the executive has followed from the start” is the outlet’s reading. It is not adopted. The piece writes that official counts diverge and that “at least 80,000” entered. That figure is El País’s wording. It is not merged with Marlaska’s 72,000 or with the Civil Guard estimate of about 88,146.
- El Mundo’s headline says the CNI report “clashes” with the police reports, and the outlet writes that the text “exonerates” Rabat. “Clashes” and “exonerates” are the outlet’s words. They are not a resolution. El Mundo and Europa Press also describe the CENIF report that names 18 Moroccan officials. That conclusion stays the CENIF’s, on the 13 November card. Being named there is not a charge. This card does not choose between the two reports.
- El País on 17 November attributes to the CNI, among others, these differences with 2021: the context (then a “direct and deliberate state operation”; before the summer of 2026, relations at “an excellent moment”), social networks, the profile of those who crossed, the absence of smuggling networks, and the manner of entry and return. “At least 80,000” is that piece’s figure; it writes that official counts diverge. It is not adopted. It is not the comparison the Civil Guard makes of 2021, 2024 and 2026, which is on another card.
Sources
- NEWS ARTICLERTVELa Guardia Civil ve insuficiente la información del CNI sobre Ceuta
- NEWS ARTICLEEuropa PressEl CNI no ve evidencias de que la entrada masiva en Ceuta fuera "instigada, planeada o coordinada" por Marruecos
- NEWS ARTICLEEl PaísEl CNI concluye que “no se han obtenido evidencias” que vinculen la entrada masiva de Ceuta con una acción del Estado marroquí
- REPORTEl MundoEl CNI choca con los informes policiales y dice que "no hay evidencias" que atribuyan la entrada masiva en Ceuta a "una acción instigada, planeada o coordinada por las autoridades marroquíes"
- NEWS ARTICLEEl PaísEl CNI detalla diez diferencias entre el asalto de Ceuta de 2021 y el de julio pasado para excluír la autoría de Marruecos