Fact
The Civil Guard calls the CNI report of 29 July partial and insufficient
Permanent link https://ceutafacts.org/en/fichas/gc-cni-parcial-20261116/
On 16 November RTVE describes a Civil Guard document, also dated 11 November and sent to the judge. It says the CNI report of 29 July was not an early warning. It calls it “partial” and “insufficient” for sizing the threat. A sudden confluence of factors on social networks is “the hypothesis considered most probable,” “although not the only one,” not a finding. El País writes 29 June in that passage; RTVE and Europa Press write 29 July. No date is chosen. It is not a judicial pronouncement and it does not settle the clash between Sanz and Pérez Triano. On 17 November El Español and Antena 3 describe, on another card, a hypothesis about a possible later entry. It is not declared to be this document.
- RTVE, which says it has had access, writes that the armed institute holds that the CNI report was “partial” and “insufficient” to “size the threat” and could not convey “the qualitative leap between an ordinary call and the materialisation of a crisis of an exceptional character.” Europa Press’s standfirst quotes the same two adjectives. In the body, Europa Press and El País print “partial insufficient information” as the sentence they attribute to the document. The document is not public. This archive has not seen it. The assessment is that of a body which also received the 29 July warning. It is not a ruling.
- RTVE quotes the Civil Guard: “the hypothesis considered most probable,” “although not the only one,” is that the mass event “could have been generated in a confluence of a multitude of potentially disconcerting factors, suddenly in a very short time,” “highly driven on social networks.” That is a hypothesis the outlet attributes to the document. It is not a finding of this archive. RTVE also prints, without accents, that the events of 2024 and 2026 “reflect internal vulnerabilities and a reactive management of the security forces,” and that 2021 was an instrument of Moroccan foreign policy. “Around 10,000” in that sentence is RTVE’s. It is not the comparison Europa Press attributes to the CNI, which is on the other card. The two comparisons are not merged.
- El País writes that the information the CNI shared on “29 June” “cannot be considered” an “early warning.” RTVE and Europa Press date that information to 29 July. This archive does not choose. El País describes a missed WhatsApp call at 13:53, a seven-minute call at 14:02 and 273 entries in 24 hours. Those times and that 273 are El País’s account of the document. They are not merged with the times already on the cards about Gonzalo Sanz. El País attributes to the document that Moroccan authorities intercepted 493 of 1,109 swimming attempts between the morning of 29 July and the morning of 30 July, and the sentence that “it cannot be concluded that the Moroccan authorities acted with an evident dereliction.” That 493 and that 1,109 are the figures in that piece. El País then calls this a contradiction with the CENIF. “Contradiction” is the outlet’s framing. This card does not resolve the two reports.
- RTVE writes that annexes of the Defence Staff, inside the Civil Guard document, assessed on 29 July that a mass jump of the fence the next day was “unlikely,” and on 30 July that Moroccan connivance was not assessed as probable. “Unlikely” and “not probable” are those assessments, as RTVE reports them. They are not findings. The 18 November statement of Pérez Triano is still ahead. This document does not settle what Sanz says he passed on and what Pérez Triano says he did not receive.
Sources
- NEWS ARTICLERTVELa Guardia Civil ve insuficiente la información del CNI sobre Ceuta
- NEWS ARTICLEEuropa PressEl CNI no ve evidencias de que la entrada masiva en Ceuta fuera "instigada, planeada o coordinada" por Marruecos
- NEWS ARTICLEEl PaísEl CNI concluye que “no se han obtenido evidencias” que vinculen la entrada masiva de Ceuta con una acción del Estado marroquí